Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore

With expanding urban populations and evolving consumption patterns, cities are faced with challenges pertaining to waste management. Traditional approaches centered on collection and disposal currently seem inadequate in the face of serious environmental concerns and resource scarcity. Waste management has become a focused topic to address, being introduced as a key strategy towards circular economies. The Zero Waste concept hopes to transform the way cities manage urban waste and build supportive cultures around it.

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 2 of 10Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 3 of 10Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 4 of 10Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 5 of 10Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - More Images+ 5

Aside from being a memorable phrase, the Zero Waste concept describes a philosophy around redesigning community relationships to resources and waste. It steps away from traditional waste management practices and their narrow views of effective disposal. The practice proposes a circular system where discarded materials are reimagined as resources with another life, completely eliminating the very concept of waste.

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 4 of 10
South Beach / Foster + Partners. Image © Nigel Young

The approach views "waste" as a flaw in the design process and general ethos around production and consumption. The lens of waste as a resource also lends itself to waste prevention, and demands a shift in thinking about product design, manufacturing, consumer behavior, and urban infrastructure. 


Related Article

Sustainable Policy: How Deconstruction Plans Are Revolutionizing Construction Waste Management in the United States

Zero Waste Cities

Cities around the world are embracing Zero Waste principles in their urban design. Two cases across the world showcase innovative methods of integrating waste management into the healthy urbanism: 

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 5 of 10
Waste collecting in Paris. Image Courtesy of Paris Media Center

Singapore: The Pneumatic Waste Conveyance System

Singapore, known for its forward-thinking urban planning, has implemented a Pneumatic Waste Conveyance System (PWCS) in several residential areas. This underground network of pipes uses vacuum technology to transport waste from individual buildings to a centralized collection point. The system eliminates the need for traditional garbage trucks, reducing traffic congestion and air pollution while improving hygiene and aesthetics.

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 9 of 10
Singapore street. Image © Shadow of light via Shutterstock

In the Yuhua estate, one of the first to adopt PWCS, residents simply deposit their waste into inlets located in common areas. The waste is then whisked away underground to a central collection station, where it's compacted and sorted for recycling or disposal. This system not only streamlines waste collection but also encourages residents to be more mindful of their waste production, as the process becomes more visible and integrated into daily life.

San Francisco: Designing for Diversion

San Francisco has long been at the forefront of the Zero Waste movement, aiming to achieve zero waste to landfill or incineration by 2030. The city's approach focuses on making waste diversion as convenient as possible through thoughtful design of both buildings and public spaces.

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 8 of 10
San Francisco: street in the financial district on weekend. Blue, green and black trash cans are on sidewalk behind the restaurants and offices.. Image © Goncharovaia via Shutterstock

New buildings in San Francisco are required to include adequate space for three waste streams: recyclables, compostables, and landfill-bound trash. This design mandate ensures that residents and businesses have easy access to proper waste sorting facilities. In public spaces, the city has deployed smart waste bins that use solar power to compact trash and send alerts when they're full, optimizing collection routes and reducing truck trips.

Moreover, San Francisco has invested in education and outreach programs to help residents understand proper sorting techniques. The city's colorful three-bin system (blue for recyclables, green for compostables, and black for landfill) is ubiquitous, creating a consistent visual language for waste diversion across the urban landscape.

Design Guidelines from Zero Waste Concept

Drawing from these case studies and the broader Zero Waste philosophy, several key design guidelines emerge for urban planners and architects. At the scale of a building, the integration of waste management systems early in the design process ensures adequate space and provision for the access for multiple waste streams. Equal convenience for recycling, composting, and trash disposal should also be factored in to encourage proper segregation of domestic waste. At the city level, urban designs have opportunities to explore collection methods such as Singapore's pneumatic system or automated containment to minimize the stagnation of waste in public spaces. It is of great importance for streetscapes to accommodate waste collection mechanisms and encourage public behavior towards their optimal use.

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 7 of 10
Best Practices for Urban Collection by Zero Waste Design. Image Courtesy of Zero Waste Design

Technology may also lend itself to promote waste management practices in the urban realm. Smart technology can be effective in optimizing waste collection routes. Visual cues, digital displays, and signage helps to reinforce cultures around shared space and collective stewardship, alluding to best practices in public waste management. Throughout the city, consistent visual cues and signage should be created to reinforce proper waste sorting habits. Public spaces should also strive to influence waste reduction practices by incorporating features like water fountains to reduce plastic bottle use and reusable container share programs. These guidelines collectively seek to integrate waste management into the urban fabric.

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 3 of 10
Colored trash cans in Barcelona. Image Courtesy of Zero Waste Design

Policy Design

Effective Zero Waste strategies extend beyond physical infrastructure, demanding supportive policies that incentivize waste reduction and diversion. These policies should encompass a range of approaches, from financial incentives to regulatory requirements. Implementing "save-as-you-throw" systems can encourage residents to reduce waste and sort properly by charging based on non-recyclable waste production. Integrating waste management plans into the building approval process ensures waste considerations are part of initial designs. Policies supporting the circular economy, such as extended producer responsibility programs, can make manufacturers accountable for their products' entire lifecycle.

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 10 of 10
San Francisco City Lombard Street Bay View. Image © Gege X Media via Shutterstock

Creating incentives for businesses adopting Zero Waste practices or developing innovative technologies can drive private sector engagement. Setting clear, ambitious Zero Waste goals for the city, coupled with regular progress reporting, maintains momentum and accountability. Finally, investing in public education programs is crucial to ensure residents understand and actively participate in Zero Waste initiatives. Together, these policy measures create a comprehensive framework that supports and accelerates the transition to a Zero Waste urban environment.

Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore  - Image 2 of 10
The Giving Garden @ Kim Tian West, developed by the Tanjong Pagar-Tiong Bahru Citizens' Consultative Committee, Kim Tian West Residents' Committee, the National Parks Board and the Tanjong Pagar Town Council. Image Courtesy of National Parks Board

The Zero Waste approach offers a pathway to more sustainable urban environments. A rethought relationship to waste and smart management - through the design of interventions at the urban and building scale - will help transform cities into models of resource efficiency and community environmental stewardship. By rethinking our relationship with waste and integrating smart management strategies into the very design of our buildings and public spaces, we can transform our cities into models of resource efficiency and environmental stewardship. The journey to Zero Waste is complex and challenging, but as cities like Singapore and San Francisco demonstrate, it's a goal well within reach - one that promises cleaner streets, healthier communities, and circular systems.

This article is part of the ArchDaily Topics: Outdoors and the Built Environment. Every month we explore a topic in-depth through articles, interviews, news, and architecture projects. We invite you to learn more about our ArchDaily Topics. And, as always, at ArchDaily we welcome the contributions of our readers; if you want to submit an article or project, contact us.

Image gallery

See allShow less
About this author
Cite: Ankitha Gattupalli. "Zero Waste Cities: Urban Strategies from San Francisco and Singapore " 23 Sep 2024. ArchDaily. Accessed . <https://www.archdaily.com/1021366/zero-waste-cities-urban-strategies-from-san-francisco-and-singapore> ISSN 0719-8884

You've started following your first account!

Did you know?

You'll now receive updates based on what you follow! Personalize your stream and start following your favorite authors, offices and users.